The Devil in the Craft Store
Jun302007
There are pitfalls in any creative endeavor, those things that you know you shouldn’t do but they’re just so . . . seductive. Excessively long guitar solos in music. The amnesia story in fiction. Purple in the sunset in painting. And when it comes to yarn, it’s the variegated stuff.
I’m not talking about handpainted yarn, that’s a fiber of an entirely different color. I’m talking about the cheap-ass machine-made variegated yarn that crowds the shelves of craft stores everywhere. It calls to me. I yearn for it. And it makes up into the ugliest fabric you’ve ever seen.
It’s just so pretty in the skein, all those colors calling to you. And every time I think, “This time will be different.” [Next week, a post on my love life.] “This time, things will work out, this time . . .”
It never does.
It’s like that time I thought, “What if a woman overheard a guy making a bet he could get her into bed and decided to pay him back?” It called to me, I thought of all the things the woman could do, it was was colorful, it was exciting, it was gaudy but appealing. But I couldn’t get it to work (or anybody to buy it). Then, ten years after I wrote the first version of it, I looked at it and thought, “What kind of a dickhead makes a bet he can get a woman into bed?” Yes, it only took me ten years to remember that my hero had to be a decent human being. And then I had to tap dance around that premise for the rest of the book. “He didn’t make the bet, okay? She just thinks he made the bet, HE DIDN’T MAKE THE BET.”
Same thing happens when I crochet with variegated yarn.
First of all, I keep missing the big picture: machine-made variegated colors are regular (made by machine) and so will work up with regulaly spaced splotches of color instead of blending subtly. There is nothing you can do about this. And yet I kept working with it. Like these hats:

If those aren’t the Ferd and Louise of hats, I don’t what is. And this is after I fixed them. Before the brims went on, the hats were pretty much a lump of this:
The dog’s breakfast of yarn. Like the amnesiac story which I yearn to write–she doesn’t know who she is! she has to find herself literally and metaphorically!–no matter what you do with this yarn, you’re always going back to be dragged back to the same point: It doesn’t work.
Unless you embrace it totally, open your arms to the absurdity of the thing, and just run with it. Amnesia stories aren’t believable? Yeah, so? What’s your point? Believability is overrated. The same thing happens with a color pattern like this: it’s so over the top ugly that you just have to embrace it with the same trailer park sassiness of the yarn itself: beauty is overrated, I’m in this for the thrill. I made two hats with this stuff before I realized there was going to be no way to make it beautiful, so it was going to have to be Fun. The capital “F” fun, as in Fun Fur and Fun Ribbon and Oh-My-God-I-Can’t-Believe-You’re-Wearing-That-Hat Fun. Thus the green fun fur on Lousie. Still not great, so I did a mix of a purple slub yarn and purple fun fur on Ferd. That’s a beautiful hat brim, I’m here to tell you. Hat’s still ugly though. Even the ribbon can’t save the basic fabric of that variegated yarn.
So with the rest of it–never say die–I paired it with a finer cotton yarn (Senso) in the turquoise color in the vari and got a fabric I think it getting close to good (it’s the hat to the right of Ferd; I’m thinking of calling it Sally):
I think it’s because there’s one color uniting it, one theme pulling it together. Reminds me of the variegated plot threads in Don’t Look Down, where we started with the bridge, the emotionally stunted director, the randy Green Beret, the Russian Mob, Finnegan, the endangered sister, the lonely little girl, and then looked at each other and said, “Oh, hell.” Lotta bobcats in that bag. So we found or added the same thematic thread to all of the plots and subplots to weave them together, one theme attached to everything–committing to others leads to fulfillment–and the different threads of the story blended. Same thing with the turquoise Senso crochet cotton, it softened all those colors into one color family. And then I did the hat brim with a thin furry yarn that blended with the vari and softened the garishness there, too. I like Sally. She’s a quiet little hat, but she has an understated sass about her, a little “I don’t think so” under that pale turquoise hum. She works.
Have I learned my variegated lesson? Of course not. I bought this after that blue/purple/green debacle:
I look at the yarn now and think, “What was I thinking?” The light must have been different at Hobby Lobby. On this one, all I could do was bury the awful fabric under a really wide brim and a bigass pompom with a ruffle. It’s the “Look over there, it’s Haley’s Comet” theory of redirective design. I’ve tried to save books like this. You Again is this hat. No matter how many times I try to fix it, the basic form is still butt-ugly. I’m going to have to unravel that story and start over, that’s all there is to it.
I have many more varis in my yarn stash. I can’t seem to help it, it’s like making a romance hero a professional murderer, or deciding to make a heroine a professor of Ancient Mesopotamia History when you don’t know anything about Mesopotamia, ancient or otherwise except that we should get the hell out of there now, or setting a book in a theme park even though you haven’t been to a theme park in ten years and hated it then. Some of us never learn.
Thank God I don’t play guitar.
Filed in X (Everything Else) | Comments (53)
















